
Image Source: http://www.thehungergamesunitplan.com/
The benefits of reading were never something I’ve questioned. From a young age, I always loved how books could suck me in to a totally different time and place, expose me to new thoughts and ideas, and encapsulate feelings I had in more poignant and erudite ways than I could ever coin.
I love books that emphasize honor and hope, I love when characters become real to me, and I love when books make me see the world or even just a facet of it in a new light. I love when books expose a truth.
But I begin to wonder: can books actually change your mind? Sure, they may open our minds to something we hadn’t considered before, and thus may shape our opinions or way we think about things. But what about already-established opinions? Or, even more difficult, what about already-established habits and behavior? Leaving aside nonfiction, I want to focus on fiction and the use of story and allegory, metaphor, and trope to make an argument.
I started reading The Hunger Games. (If you haven’t read them and don’t like spoilers, you might want to skip the rest of this discussion because I’m going to talk about the books in a way that assumes you’ve already read them.) Right around the time Katniss’s team starts prepping her for her interview before the games in the first book, I was struck with an overwhelming sense of unease. It struck me as highly ironic, and perhaps even manipulative, that the author was sending us a message about the horrors of violence and our addiction to violence-as-entertainment simultaneously as she draws us into an addictive, violent story.
Not every one reads the books for the violence, obviously. People are drawn into the story by things like the empathetic characters (which, in that same scene before her interview the characters discuss what makes a character empathetic…again, another poke from the author), the love triangle, innocents like Rue, and heartbreaking moments like the finger-to-mouth salutes, and the underdog/David v. Goliath storyline.
Through the book, the author conducts an in-depth exploration of PTSD, how horrific events can change a person, and the power of war to strip a people of who they are. She offers a formidable indictment against society for its appetite for violence and for its capacity to sacrifice innocents for the security of the whole. And she shows how victims themselves can become perpetrators. (All themes, given my work, I’m very aware of and sensitive to, as I see in the real world where hunger is not a game, and where children are forced to do terrible things, in the name of the state, for the sake of entertainment.)
The books, as I see them, are quite bleak. I appreciate them for sucking me in and exposing truth, but the trajectory of the book is not, in the end, a happy one.
And yet, there is such fanfare and great excitement surrounding the books and the movie, it strikes me as a little odd…like having a 1984 celebration or a Clockwork Orange party, featuring the Manchurian Candidate.
Again, not everyone is in it for the violence or to revel in dystopianism. But when people start saying that it makes them want to watch Battle Royale again to see kids duke it out with other kids, and speculate on what person would live or die if it happened to them, and marketing execs know it’s targeted to young adults who also drive the horror film industry…it’s hard to argue that the violence isn’t at least some part of the draw.
I watch movies with violence in them too – generally of the political thriller variety. And yet, as sympathetic as I am to the books’ argument, is this going to make me stop watching violent movies? Doubt it. As much as people might get the central message, will it actually change our minds about how we view violence-as-entertainment? Do we accept we have a natural human proclivity to schadenfreude, or do books like these actually encourage us to change our behavior?
These books are being included in high school classrooms and Christian Bible study groups and book clubs around the country, ostensibly to share some of the books’ lessons with kids in an easily digestible format. And yet, as a teacher who created lesson plans around the books to share with other teachers, has said, “Students will be so hooked on Katniss Everdeen’s struggle to survive in the murderous arena, they won’t even notice that they are learning about dystopian literature and totalitarianism.” She said it as if it’s a good thing.
This raises a question for me about the power of books to really change minds. Books like 1984, due to their literary nature, will only reach a narrow audience. Books like The Hunger Games have a wide, popular appeal…but do the elements that make them popular also distract from the underlying themes? Do we nod our heads blithely at the lessons and societal criticisms, while focusing on the love stories, rebellious spirit, and fantastic costumes and imagery? People who are averse to violence and violent themes don’t need the books. But people who tend to approach violence in ways that are sometimes unthinking…or worse…what effect, if any, do the books have on them?
At the end of the day, the question I’m left with is: do books preach only to the choir?
This week, my Bigger Picture Moment came not in the form of an answer or revelation, but a tricky question to which I have no answer. I’m open and curious to hear what others think. It’s possibly a provocative question, but hopefully not a judgmental one. Sometimes, for me, part of living life with intention is asking myself questions, even if I might not like my own answer.

Each Thursday, we come together to celebrate living life with intention by capturing a glimmer of the bigger picture through a simple moment. Have you found yourself in such a moment lately? Share it with us!
Live.
Reflect on the moments that shimmered in your heart.
Capture.
Harvest them!
Share.
Link up your gleaned moment this week at Hyacynth’s! Please be sure to link to your post, not your blog, and include our button or a link back to the host page.
Encourage.
Visit some of the other participants and encourage each other in this journey we call life.